Holford Watch: Patrick Holford, nutritionism and bad science

Entries from January 2008

Food for the Brain: Child Survey: Review Part 4

January 30, 2008 · 13 Comments

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University (and also Head of Science and Education at Biocare) and Drew Fobbester are joint researchers and authors of the Food for the Brain Child Survey, September 2007 (pdf). Holford Watch has taken an interest in this report: so much so that we have dedicated three posts to looking at the literature overview - Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3.

In short, out of 10 references, 1 was appropriate, albeit mis-reported, so, if that sort of thing bothers you as it does us, then not one of the references is used in an acceptable manner. Not one. One of them doesn’t even exist. (more…)

Categories: Food for the brain · Holford · patrick holford · referenciness · scienciness · truthiness
Tagged: , , , , , , , ,

Holford’s Health Products for Life breaches ASA rules on truthfulness and substantiation

January 30, 2008 · 6 Comments

Today, the ASA have ruled against Health Products for Life (HPFL): a supplement company that Professor Patrick Holford (Head of Science and Education at Biocare) sold to Biocare, and which has a website - and sells pills - with a picture of Holford’s face on. Holford is beginning to amass a collection of ASA rulings both for his own offerings and those for products that he endorses. (more…)

Categories: ASA · IgG tests · food intolerance · health · health products for life · patrick holford · yorktest
Tagged: , , , , , , , ,

Holford uses “crazy” as a diagnostic term for schizophrenic people

January 28, 2008 · 13 Comments

Prof Patrick Holford of Teesside University presents himself as an expert in mental health and nutrition, and a number of bona fide mental health charities - including Mind - are affiliated with his Food for the Brain charity. I was therefore surprised to hear Holford on BBC London, referring to a schizophrenic client as “crazy” which is rather a culturally-loaded term. A valued correspondent then informed me that the same term is used on the Food for the Brain website. I find this quite surprising - ‘crazy’ is a rather offensive way to describe schizophrenic people, and a pretty unproductive diagnostic or descriptive term.

First to the BBC interview: Holford states that he “worked with one girl, she was schizophrenic…and she was crazy and she’d seen many counsellors”. (more…)

Categories: Food for the brain · patrick holford
Tagged: , ,

Dore releases news of groundbreaking autism treatment in the prestigious medical journal The Leamington Courier

January 27, 2008 · 7 Comments

A quick break from your usual Holford coverage, to note how excited I was when I saw Wynford Dore claiming a number of breakthroughs in understanding and treating of Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASDs). However, when I followed the link he gave - expecting to find an article in a journal like Nature Neuroscience or The Lancet - I found an article in, um, that well-known medical journal The Leamington Courier. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with local papers - but they’re not peer-reviewed, and not exactly where one expects to break the news of one’s great research achievements.

Naturally, an article in a local paper doesn’t give the detail that one would want about methodology etc. However, among other things, The Leamington Courier notes that only 56 children with diagnoses of ASD (or, as The Courier tactfully puts it “diagnosed as suffering from autism”) have been through the programme. (more…)

Categories: Dore · autism · autistic spectrum disorders

Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 2

January 26, 2008 · 7 Comments

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University is a staunch supporter of Dr Andrew Wakefield and in 2007 set out his case as to why others should likewise support Wakefield. Holford has updated his website to explore the issue: Patrick Holford’s Concerns About the MMR Vaccine.

Patrick Holford claims to have remarkable insight into the causation of autism and how to “bring them back” when children are on the autistic spectrum. He suggests that there is hard evidence that links MMR and autism. (more…)

Categories: Andrew Wakefield · MMR · Wakefield · autism · autistic spectrum disorders · immunization · measles · vaccination · vaccines
Tagged: , , , , , , , , ,

Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 1

January 25, 2008 · 5 Comments

Categories: Andrew Wakefield · Holford · MMR · Wakefield · autistic spectrum disorders · brian deer · immunization · measles · patrick holford
Tagged: , , , , , , ,

Food for the Brain: Child Survey: Review Part 3

January 25, 2008 · 6 Comments

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University (and also Head of Science and Education at Biocare) and Drew Fobbester are joint researchers and authors of the Food for the Brain Child Survey, September 2007 (pdf). This is the third of three Holford Watch posts in which we explain why the literature overview in the FFTB Child Survey is inadequate: some of the claims made in the review are not supported by relevant references or studies of sufficient quality. Part 1 discusses the claims relating to supplements and children’s diet. Part 2 examines the claims made for the benefit of a balanced glycaemic load diet for children. For Part 3, we discuss the claims for the alleged incidence of food sensitivities and gluten sensitivity.
(more…)

Categories: Food for the brain · Food for the brain foundation · food intolerance · health · patrick holford
Tagged: , , , , , , , ,

Quackometer blog threatened with spurious legal action. Again.

January 23, 2008 · 6 Comments

A short break from Patrick Holford coverage, to report that the Quackometer’s host has been sent a wonderfully entertaining e-mail on behalf of ‘Professor Dr’ Joseph Chikelue Obi: demanding that Netcetera

immediately shut down the website and delete all of the defamatory material relating to the Royal College of Alternative Medicine, Professor Dr Obi and our clients` lawfully registered Trademarks.

It’s impossible to read this e-mail without picturing someone sticking their little finger in their mouth and stroking a fluffy cat.

Worryingly, though, both the Quackometer’s hosts and Google appear to have taken this nonsense seriously (more…)

Categories: Uncategorized
Tagged: , , , , ,

Patrick Holford: Star of the Blogosphere

January 18, 2008 · No Comments

Here at Holfordwatch, we’re delighted to see that so many blogs are giving Professor Patrick Holford plenty of attention: the new Holford Myths blog, Damian Thompson’s Telegraph blog and today’s Skeptic’s Circle. The excellent Holford Myths blog launched recently, offering a summary of some of Holford’s greatest hits. They have apparently also been contacted by Holford recently.  (more…)

Categories: patrick holford
Tagged: , , , , , ,

Food for the Brain: Child Survey: Review Part 2

January 17, 2008 · 9 Comments

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University (and also Head of Science and Education at Biocare) and Drew Fobbester are joint researchers and authors of the Food for the Brain Child Survey, September 2007 (pdf). This is the second of three Holford Watch posts in which we explain why the literature overview in the FFTB Child Survey is inadequate: some of the claims made in the review are not supported by relevant references or studies of sufficient quality. Part 1 discussed the claims relating to supplements and children’s diet. Part 2 examines the claims made for the benefit of a balanced glycaemic load diet for children.
(more…)

Categories: Food for the brain · Food for the brain foundation · Holford · children · food intolerance · food sensitivity · gluten intolerance · glycaemic load · glycemic load · intelligence · intolerance · nutrition · patrick holford · referenciness · truthiness
Tagged: , , , , , , , ,